I’ve been a fan Upton and Halstead’s evolution as a pairing, but I can’t help but feel that an engagement would be doomed if Season 9 reveals that Halstead said yes after how and why she asked.
If they get engaged at some point, it shouldn’t be like this!
Plus, the man has been known to make some bad decisions when thinking with his heart over his head, and he has the scars to prove it.
He’s a perceptive enough guy to know that something was off and that he didn’t have the full story, but he also loves her, and I’m probably going to be nervous about it up until the Season 9 premiere.