From questionable saves to superfluous advice that doesn’t feature any true criticism, the Idol trio have often inspired a vocal group of viewers who want judges that are a bit more critical of competitors and their abilities.
Will Idol give that group what they want, or continue to keep its mostly positive-minded judges on staff?
Then again, American Idol isn’t really about the judges, and there has been some criticism directed at the current group and their decision making over the course of Season 17.