Unfortunately, his rocker skills weren’t as great as his competitors, and he ended up being unmasked after losses to the Flower and Penguin.
Pinsky said he had originally gone into the show hoping to do some opera (he’d done opera in college), but the look of the Eagle demanded a more rock-n-roll persona.
Somewhere between that they get into costume, which for Dr. Drew Pinsky was an Eagle who looked like someone who would’ve been spotted at Woodstock back in the day.