The themed night favors competitors with big voices and a vast love of Disney, but the limited song choices can potentially knock out unique singers whose voices just aren’t meant to mesh with the likes of Celine Dion or Elton John.
American Idol’s Disney Night, in my personal opinion, does more harm than good for competitors on the show.
Disney songs are classics, without a doubt, but so many of them are performed in a style that’s unlike how most modern pop music is put together.
That’s true of all themed nights on the show, to be fair, but at least other themes can be justified for using songs that are commonly heard on the radio.