After a while, though, the rumor mill shifted its focus to get fans talking about who Cavallari and Cutler might be involved with for post-divorce relationships, with the former Laguna Beach star inspiring much speculation after posting a pic of herself with ex-co-star Stephen Colletti.
Imagine how interesting future holiday get-togethers might get if one or both of them are in new relationships.
Alas, most of those rumors have turned out to be just that, but as always, fans are on the lookout for more follow-ups.
It was back in April when Kristin Cavallari and Jay Cutler first announced they were getting divorced, with plenty of rumors rising up to explain how their relationship went downhill over time, especially after details from the divorce papers were revealed.