Friar Pete was first introduced in Season 2, Episode 2, “Speak of the Devil,” as Martin’s consultant at Claremont.
And in true Malcolm Bright fashion, he had to nearly get himself killed, in the moments before Pete lost his own life.
It was ultimately revealed that he was a serial killer who pursued his victims due to religious delusion.
All in all, while the scene was massively dramatic, it still holds plenty of weight due to the importance of Friar Pete – and the fact that Christian Borle didn’t have to watch himself overact.