Maybe Peter’s mom wants Madi to be the one he takes home but he has to do some Cassie-style wooing first?
Maybe she doesn’t want to get engaged without her dad’s blessing.
Reality Steve’s spoilers have noted that Madison is the virgin that Victoria F. was talking about in the premiere’s full season trailer tease.
But just leaving the show dating would be too much like what Bachelor Colton Underwood already did last year, plus plenty of Bachelors haven’t gotten engaged in the end.