The best choice would be, you guessed it, Madison, because she’s already met his family once, on their first one-on-one date, and Peter will take his final two ladies to meet the folks.
This seems to mean that Madi will get to bond with his mom again, after finally showing up for that rose ceremony, which will lead to Mama Weber’s plea for Peter to go get her.
The Women Tell All promo that shows Peter heading to this house also features the now-infamous clip of Peter’s sobbing mother telling him, “bring her home to us!” and we’ve all been wondering who could have gotten this lovely women so riled up.