Without going into spoilers, viewers’ safe wager is on Jillian’s childhood friend Pretzel Jack inspiring the most giddily horrified reactions.
The grotesque and misunderstood oddball is portrayed by America’s Got Talent standout Troy James, whose seemingly impossible body is capable of fitting into any nook and cranny available.
Even if he didn’t hauntingly stalk victims before possibly turning their faces into jellied mush, Pretzel Jack inspires blinding terror just by happily throwing his hands up to say hello.