Evan fell in love with one of the single women in his villa, Morgan Lolar.
Evan officially broke things off with a distraught Kaci in the finale and actually proposed to Morgan as well.
We do know what happened with Evan Smith’s time on Temptation Island, which started when he entered the show with his high school sweetheart of ten years, Kaci Campbell.
Their story was particularly heartbreaking because while Kaci realized while being apart from Evan that she really wanted to be with him, Evan had a different outcome.