I Need To Talk About Why Agatha All Along's Nicholas Scratch Backstory Doesn't Quite Add Up For Me

But I was mentally invested enough in Agatha and Rio’s past that I downright needed the latter to have been actively malevolent regarding Nicholas’ death.

It also left viewers with many lingering questions about Billy, Jen and more, but I’m focusing here on the life and death of Nicholas Scratch.

Spoilers below for anyone who hasn’t yet watched Agatha All Along’s two-episode finale via Disney+ subscription, so be warned!