Unfortunately, they all soon learned they weren’t talking to Josie, but the dark Josie alter ego who wasn’t about to be put behind bars.
Once Josie awoke, Lizzie apologized for being so self-consumed and not recognizing the black magic that was within her twin sister sooner.
Lizzie was ultimately saved from dark Josie’s wrath via Hope’s last minute intervention.
Once out of the simulation, the two filled everyone else in on the plan and Josie was moved to a cell until they could talk to her and figure it all out.