On his first reaction to the script, Nicholas wasn’t a huge fan, and apparently threw the script out after only reading a small amount of it.
The 90s were a different time, and I guess it was pretty uncommon to read a script that featured teen sex with little subtly.
He then called his agent to complain, thinking that he was actually reading the script for a porn film.
In an interview with PeopleTV (via Entertainment Weekly) Thomas Ian Nicholas and Tara Reid, who starred as couple Kevin and Vicky, looked back on the 1999 comedy American Pie.