The key here is that Super Troopers 2 does not recycle The Cat Game and offer it up in the same fashion, but with a brand-new victim.
Rather than try to recapture the glory of an old joke completely, Super Troopers 2 puts a spin on it by letting Larry Johnson be the one who’s having fun, with the cops dumbfounded about what’s going on.
Instead, Broken Lizard seems to understand that we have already seen this joke before and that it will never live up to the legacy of the original Cat Game — something that Super Troopers fans still play to this very day.
On top of all of that, the bit ends with an out-of-nowhere finale (which we won’t fully give away here) that perfectly punctuates the return to the Super Troopers universe and amps up the joke by a notch or two.