The series ultimately averaged 4.7 million viewers and a 1.4 in the valuable 18-49 demographic, and those numbers evidently were not enough for Fox to order a second season.
As recently as January, the Fox CEO was praising Pitch for its delayed viewership and loyal core audience.
Despite the continued enthusiasm of fans and the valiant #RenewPitch campaign on Twitter, we’ll never see a Season 2.
The show actually ended its first season back in December 2016, so fans (and the actors) have been waiting quite a while for news of renewal or cancellation, and there was reason to be optimistic.