The guess made me a wee bit suspicious of how the judges come to their conclusions for guesses, especially when nothing in the clue package teased Tina Fey for me, and I’ll definitely be watching future guesses from judges more closely going forward.
It was almost too perfect of a moment, and typically when things seem too good to be true on reality television competitions, they are.
I’m not saying Robin Thicke was fed his guess by a producer, or that he may have seen something behind the scenes he shouldn’t have, but I am saying it’s very strange he guessed Tina Fey given the circumstances.