Their guesses ranged from former Destiny’s Child singers Kelly Rowland and Michelle Williams to Dawn Robinson to Hailee Steinfeld, with Nicole Scherzinger saying that she had to be a “white Kelly Rowland.”
Now, to be fair, the judges (and guest panelist Kenan Thompson) were the ones who were totally shocked, but that’s not the case for everybody.
Many folks on social media came to the conclusion that Rumer Willis was likely beneath the Lion’s mask, so viewers watching from home probably weren’t as amazed as the judges.