For his part, Peth appeared in Season 12 of The Bachelorette as a candidate for JoJo Fletcher’s heart.
Nolan first appeared in Season 21 of The Bachelor, in which Nick Viall was looking for a lady love.
Neither were successful on their first attempts to find reality TV love, but it seems that their struggles on The Bachelor and The Bachelorette were worth the heartache, as they’re now engaged.
Taylor Nolan and Derek Peth met on the currently-airing fourth season of Bachelor in Paradise, and it was clear right away that they were having more luck in this series than they did on their earlier ventures in the franchise.