Ken Jeong was one of the most embarrassed of the bunch, as Gasteyer reminded him they had worked together on A Christmas Story Live!
Jeong admitted he forgot he did that project, otherwise he might’ve remembered her musical number and her great voice.
All the judges were surprised, save one.
Jenny McCarthy is on a hot streak this season, and while she was originally on the fence about which former Saturday Night Live actress was under the mask, she ultimately chose Ana Gasteyer as her final option.