The Turtle dropped some clues that seemed to hint at a boy band past and early musical success, which fueled some serious speculation about male singers who hit it big early in their careers.
Now, two Backstreet Boys have denied living a shell of a double life, but one revealed he was originally a contender for the Turtle.
The competition on The Masked Singer Season 3 is already heating up, and fans are out in droves to try and figure out which celebrities are singing from behind the masks.