All of the sudden, a twist created out of fairness to competitors robbed of a live-stage experience has become unfair to the current season competitors.
I won’t be the least bit surprised if he ends up the 10th contestant in Season 19.
I’m okay with the idea of Comeback Night but bringing back a runner-up or even third place to compete is just too unfair to the current season, especially when they bypass a bulk of the season to get there.
I say that because Arthur Gunn nearly won American Idol once, so to give him another chance at entering the Top 10 is an insanely huge advantage for him a second go-around.